National Geographic
Menu

Cove Guardian Elora Malama West Takes on Taiji for the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society

National Geographic Society contributor Dr. Jordan Schaul has embarked on a new endeavor to find young nature conservation crusaders and tell their story through exclusive interviews for NAT GEO NEWS WATCH.

I believe in citizen science and informed citizen advocacy. I’m particularly impressed by young people who advocate on behalf the voiceless creatures of nature. We need more knowledgable young crusaders on this planet helping the animal kingdom and protecting nature and natural resources.

I have launched a new interview series with some young crusaders who are making a difference for animal kind. My first candidate selected to participate in this inaugural interview series is Ms. Elora Malama West with the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society.
photo
Elora West (SSCS)


Elora’s autobiography:
Elora Malama West is a home-schooled teenage activist. She is on the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society (SSCS) Board of Advisors for Children’s Education and Activities. She is currently 19 (dob: 11/09/93). West will finish her associate degree December 2013 and is applying for schools with Bachelor degree programs in media activism and visual journalism.

In the fall of 2010 at age 16, Elora accompanied her father, Scott West, to Taiji, Japan for the first SSCS Cove Guardian campaign. They spent three months on the ground reporting everyday about the plight of the dolphins. While there Elora began a blog, A Teenage Activist: This Girl’s Soapbox and encouraged thousands of people to call the Japanese embassies in their area to protest the dolphin slaughter. Her young age combined with her blog reports brought international attention to what is happening in Taiji, Japan.

During her time in Japan, Elora participated in the first ever meeting between the mayor of Taiji and the activists opposing the town’s annual slaughter; and gave a speech at the Foreign Correspondents Club of Japan about the issue in Taiji.  Elora hopes to send a message to her generation that you are never too young to make your voice heard.

Elora also spent time in Australia aboard the Steve Irwin. She worked with SSCS Australia in preparation for Operation Zero Tolerance, the 2012-2013 campaign against Japanese whaling in Antarctic waters. In April 2013, she joined SSCS US at the Columbia River for the Dam Guardian campaign in an effort to end the slaughter of sea lions in Washington and Oregon.

Interview:

Jordan: What exactly is going on in Japan that is so reprehensible regarding cetaceans?

Elora: The genocide and captive trade of what many scientists consider to be non-human persons. Cetaceans have proven to be highly intelligent creatures. Thomas White (philosopher and author of “In Defense of Dolphins”) characterizes them as non-human persons. The only thing separating cetaceans from us are opposable thumbs. Just as we oppose the genocide of people in different cultures, this is another culture. These are intelligent, sentient, and social/ family oriented beings, their home is just in the ocean.

Taiji has been drive hunting and killing an estimated 2,000 cetaceans annually since about 1970, with 20,000 killed annually throughout Japan. In recent years, numbers have been dwindling. Our records showed that 803 cetaceans were killed in Taiji last year, with 15 deaths being related to juveniles released and washing back up.

We believe this low number of kills is because fewer pods exist in Japanese waters.

Before the mass slaughter begins, trainers from the local dolphinariums come and select dolphins to be sold into captivity around the world. Without the demand for dolphins and whales for swim with dolphin programs the slaughter would cease to exist. Our records show 236 cetaceans were taken for captivity in Taiji last year.

Jordan: I have not seen the movie the Cove. Would you recommend it to me?

dolphins-jumping-cove_11529_600x450
Trained dolphins, Taiji, Japan (NAT GEO)

Elora: I would. I think it is a very important movie to see. Director Louie Psihoyos made a remarkable film that not only sheds light on a very barbaric thing, but also opens your eyes about the issues of toxic meat, the lucrative captive industry and the harmful effects on cetaceans, and the incredible intelligence of these animals.

As Sea Shepherd founder Captain Watson has often said, we search the universe and beyond looking for intelligent life to communicate with, and we have this incredible being right on our very planet that we cannot understand… and probably should.

The movie is set up like a spy thriller at some points. I promise you won’t be watching 2 hours of slaughter, you don’t actually see any killing until the last 15 minutes of the film.

The movie won the Academy Award in 2010 for best documentary.

dolphin-meat-supermarket_11530_600x450
Dolphin meat (NAT GEO)

Elora: There have been a few studies done in somewhat recent years. There was the Blue Voice study in 2008.

The first test conducted in 2008 by BlueVoice.org of meat from a bottlenose dolphin revealed Mercury at 7.20ppm – eighteen times higher than the maximum level permitted under Japanese health standards.”

There was the study conducted in the Cove. If I remember correctly, one sample of dolphin meat from local supermarkets was at 2000ppm: a very high and toxic level of mercury.

The health department in Japan has said that pregnant women should not eat the meat because it causes birth defects.

Dolphins and whales are apex predators, and the ocean is downhill from everything. They are eating PCBs, mercury, and many other pollutants. Those chemicals and compounds work their way up the food chain. Tuna has been tested recently to be very toxic as well. The studies I listed above were conducted a few years ago, but if anything I am sure things have only gotten worse.

Jordan: Some captive facilities around the world are supporting this trade. How so and how do you know?

Elora: I’ve witnessed the transfer of live dolphins from Taiji to dolphinariums and museums in Japan, as well as dolphins being packed up for shipment internationally. I saw on countless occasions dolphins and small whales taken from Taiji’s cove and placed in captive holding pens or transferred to one of the nearby museums/dolphin parks. Trainers from these local dolphinariums come and select which whales they will use to fill the orders coming in from all over the world. They lock the cetaceans up and break them, training them to rely on humans for food.

honshu-dalls-porpoises-dolphin-hunt_11623_600x450
Harvested Dall’s porpoises (NAT GEO)

While I was on the ground, during the first three months of Operation Infinite Patience, we kept seeing dolphins loaded onto trucks. They were put in crates just wide enough and long enough to have the animals lay there. Then they would fill the crate with a little water and pump something into the water (we think a light sedation drug). One day Scott West and I decided to follow a truck to see where it dropped off the dolphins. It was an 8- or 9-hour road trip and we managed to not be seen during the entire tailing. We followed the truck into a dolphinarium called “Suma Aqualife Park”. What is interesting about this is IMATA (The International Marine Animal Trainer’s Association) claim they have nothing to do with Taiji. However, Suma Aqualife Park was represented at IMATA’s next marine animal trainer conference.

Sea Shepherd’s Cove Guardians have followed trucks of live Taiji dolphins to airports, for shipment out of Japan. Taiji receives orders for dolphins and small whales (a prize bottlenose dolphin, one that looks like Flipper, is the most valuable). Ceta Base has tracking information on all these dolphins.

Trainers from the local dolphinariums come and select these cetaceans for shipment, and then leave minutes before slaughter begins.

The live trade of cetaceans into the United States is illegal, but captive born cetaceans can be shipped inside the country. We believe cetaceans come from Taiji, or similar drive fisheries, and somewhere in the world the paperwork is falsified to state that the dolphin was born in captivity, allowing the shipment of live caught dolphins into the United States.

Without the revenue of the captive trade, Taiji could not afford to keep operating their boats with simply the sales of cetacean meat. It’s our understanding that dead dolphins are worth around $600, while a trained captive dolphin can sell for hundreds of thousands. All captive dolphin industries support this trade. Without the demand for live dolphins and whales… so people can watch them jump through hoops, so people can kiss them and hug them… the drive fisheries like Taiji and the slaughter of cetaceans would eventually come to an end. Our slogan: Don’t buy a ticket.

Jordan: What are celebrities saying about Taiji? I know people like Jennifer Aniston and the outspoken animal advocates the Barbi Twins are up in arms. What about others? What are they saying?

Elora: I’ve personally seen the passion for stopping this slaughter and captive trade from celebrities like the Barbi Twins and Leilani Munter. But many of our #tweet4taiji tweets have been shared by celebrities, including Danny DeVito and Kirstie Alley.

Sea Shepherd has celebrity supporters including Ian Somerhalder, Clive Standen, Pamela Anderson, Michelle Rodriguez, Joe Perry and Steven Tyler of Aerosmith, Martin Sheen, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Xavier Rudd and the Smashing Pumpkins. This is just to name a few. These people have come out in support of Sea Shepherd’s mission and campaigns. I assume that means they support our work in Taiji as well.

We are always grateful for celebrity support. However, we welcome and are equally appreciative of the support we get from ordinary, caring people around the world. We have been fortunate to have Cove Guardians from the USA, Japan, Netherlands, France, Switzerland, Canada, Germany, Australia and other nations. That cross-section of nations is a testament to the fact that people the world over see the cruelty that exists in Taiji and are willing to stand on the front lines to bring an end to it. As our credo suggests, “We will not stop until the slaughter ends.”

Please watch this compelling video titled “I am a Cove Guardian,” featuring some of our Cove Guardian crew.

Jordan: If you could make one statement, what would you say?

Elora: If there is NOT a global consciousness shift within the governments of every country and their citizens, we are going to destroy everything. No country has stepped up to the plate and taken the lead in protecting our one and only home.

A small group of committed global citizens, including children, are screaming for change and trying to push the world in that direction. Yet, they are called terrorists and pirates for defending life on earth. We will be our own undoing if this doesn’t stop.

For Jordan Schaul’s complete biography and recent posts, please visit his author page on this website.

 

Comments

  1. Patrick Corsi
    France
    July 1, 8:06 am

    Please National Geographic,get your facts straight about the Sea Shepherd organisation. It’s surprising that such a prestigious publication wouldn’t investigate deeper into the subject.

  2. Ford Elms
    St. John's Newfoundland
    July 1, 7:46 am

    I have always been a fan of National Geographic, until now. To see an organization that I have always trusted and valued give attention and worse still praise to an ignorant cultural imperialist is disgusting. NG has always been respectful of other cultures, indeed, it is from NG that I, a kid growing up in a remote isolated northern town, learned a lot about the wider world and its people. I know I am swimming against the tide in this, and I know that I will appear a narrow minded conservative. In truth I am a liberal. But being from a culture that has been attacked, demonized, and exploited by people like Elora Marama, I see clearly what she is doing, and it is NOT conservation. It is cultural imperialism pure and simple, and, as a liberal, I feel a responsibility to oppose it.

    I cannot believe I am seeing this monstrous piece of adulation of a nasty, disrespectful, ignorant bully, offensively harassing innocent people to push her particular political agenda! What next? A slander piece about how Newfoundlanders are all savages and barbarians because we hunt seals, or a piece demonizing the Faroese for their sustainable harvesting of pilot whales? Is the National Geographic now going down the politically correct road that allows for the demonization and exploitation of cultures that do not fit the urban Western urban mold?

    How about a piece on the cultures that are victimized by arrogant bullies like Elora Marama and her offensive group of Western brats feeding their egos and absolving their guilt ridden souls on the backs of the innocent? They know their urban lifestyles are damaging the planet, so to absolve themselves, they attack others who do far less damage in a sad yet grandiose bid to appear Valiant Ecowarriors defending Gaia against The Man, all while the environment goes to Hell on a handbar, species go extinct with alarming regularity, fisheries and the communities that have depended on them for centuries collapse as industrial fishing interests rape the stocks these more traditional communities have sustainably harvested for centuries. Yet, more often than not, it is these fishermen, who in many instances know only too well the destruction caused by overharvesting of the seas, who have done the least to damage the oceans, who have in many cases tried to warn the destruction was coming, and who have suffered the most from that destruction, who are attacked and exploited by bullies like Elora Marama, while those who are destroying the oceans go unnoticed. She diverts scarce resources from reputable environmental organizations who are actually trying to do something good for the Earth, yet she receives this attention? Seriously?

    Yeah, I think a piece about us would add some balance. A piece about innocent fishermen who have to endure harassment, lies, misinformation, hate speech, and carefully edited video “evidence” being used around the world to slander them and destroy their livelihoods and communities under the guise of “conservation”, who find themselves the targets of ignorant, easily manipulated celebrities, subjected to harassment by campaigns of lies, misinformation, half truths, hate speech, and bigotry by people who know nothing of their culture but are offended by things they do not understand and feel every right to force these “barbarians” to comply with their ill informed, arrogant urban attitudes. But, oh no, an ignorant, entitled narcissistic little brat going to a foreign country to insult and offend the innocent citizens, THAT gets a recognition.

    I am disgusted that National Geographic would show such disrespect and ignorance that you would go down the road of abetting the demonizing of another culture under the guise of “conservationism” and would choose to praise and “honour” someone who is fiddling while Rome burns, feeding her ego by offending and attacking innocent people, all the while pretending to be a “conservationist” while ignoring the species that are really endangered. Have you seen the hateful bigotry she posts on Facebook on a regular basis? Do you actually know what she does, or are you simply dazzled by what you naively seem to think is some modern environmental hero? How can you confuse bigoted narcisssism with conservationism? I am disgusted. I really expected better of an organization for which I have always has the greatest respect and from which I once learned a great deal. You should be ashamed!

  3. Tove Askham
    Faroe Islands
    July 1, 7:01 am

    …West will finish her associate degree December 2013 and is applying for schools with Bachelor degree programs in media activism and visual journalism…
    Need at degree to spread hatred?

  4. Jayna Hamel
    Florida
    December 3, 2013, 6:27 pm

    Please, National Geographic, do a full expose on this horrible slaughter each year in Taiji. Slaughter was suspende in 2009 but it’s started up again. This is an ugly, inhumane and horrible story but it must be told. Just today nearly 70 dolphins are corralled into the Cove and in the process of being slaughtered. Thank you!

  5. Anne Ratcliffe
    Australia
    November 2, 2013, 1:58 am

    I have a feeling we are going to be seeing a lot more of this young lady. Heartfelt thanks to you Elora and those like you who are able to articulate and raise awareness as you do.

  6. Nicky Smedley
    Hull england uk
    October 21, 2013, 1:14 pm

    Great what your doing wish I could help these defenceless mammals whom I adore. Please dont stop because I believe one day now more awareness is getting out there we will make it stop .

  7. JD
    Switzerland
    October 13, 2013, 10:13 pm

    How did you manage to keep a straight face when she came out with the “non human person” rubbish? Also you did not ask her about Bridget Bardot the celebrity they named a boat after – which considering BB has no less than FIVE convictions for racial hatred in her native France you could have challenged Sea Shepherd why name a boat after a notorious racist?

  8. Kathy Hallinan
    San Francisco
    October 13, 2013, 9:45 pm

    This issue is enormous, and must be won. Thank you thank you thank you Sea Guardians, what a job to report from the cove follow the hunters report when the cove is blue and when it is RED ….this slaughter must stop of these most certainly sentient fellow creatures here in earth ..thank you Elora and all the Cove Sea Guardians …a tough tough job to do….thank you

  9. Kirsten Massebeau
    Cannon Beach, Oregon
    October 13, 2013, 11:57 am

    When I became involved in fighting for dolphins I found my way to Elora West’s page This Girl’s SoapBox where she was reporting on the drive. She has inspired, and educated many people young and old alike about the terrible slaughter and capture of dolphins driven by the captive industry in Taiji, Japan.