National Geographic
Menu

Restoring the Urban Sea by Farming It

With 91% of the seafood that we eat in this country imported from foreign waters there is increased interest in restoring local watersheds to full productivity. While much of the dialogue about sustainable seafood focuses on maintaining adequate resources, some forms of aquaculture can actually help to regenerate ecosystems, revitalize economies, and enhance food security.

This is what I term restorative seafood; food systems that provide for our needs while actually increasing the productivity and profit of the waters that sustain us. Shellfish farming in particular — clams, mussels, and oysters — are some of my favorite examples of man’s ability to actually give back to the planet even while providing for our needs. You will find me posting on shellfish frequently in future pieces, but to introduce the topic to this forum I know of no better way than to introduce two friends, Bren Smith and Zan Romanoff, as guest contributors to Ocean Views.

Both visionaries, Bren and Zan are helping to radically alter our relationship with both the ecology and economy of our marine systems.

This piece co-authored by Bren and Zan presents a powerful argument that explains that some of the very best environmentalism is practiced on the half-shell. So read on, and then go get yourself a couple dozen oysters, a couple of beers and do your part to help revive our blue planet.

Bren Smith working on his oyster farm located in CT's Thimble Islands
Bren Smith works on his oyster farm off CT's Thimble Islands. Photo: Ron Gautreau

 

Farming the Urban Sea

By Bren Smith and Zan Romanoff

They are back: blue mussels and menhaden have returned to Long Island Sound this year in huge numbers. On this 40th anniversary of the Clean Water Act, we can celebrate their homecoming as a sign of the progress made reviving our Sound. More needs to be done, but this welcome news of cleaner waters opens the opportunity to begin farming the urban sea.

Aquaculture has rightly earned a reputation for growing low quality seafood at the expense of the environment, but a new form of ocean-friendly farming has emerged right here in Long Island Sound. These small-scale vertical farms — some of the first in the country — are designed to grow multiple species of seaweed and shellfish, have small footprints and provide an array of environmental benefits. Picture them as three-dimensional gardens, where seaweed, mussels and scallops grow at the top of the water column, stacked above oysters and clams below.

Eating local seaweed may seem exotic, but it’s coming to a plate near you. While shellfish have seen turns as both delicacies and a staple food source in our region for hundreds of years, the seaweed that grows alongside them is less familiar. It shouldn’t be, though: a native seaweed like Nori contains more vitamin C than orange juice, more calcium than milk, and more protein than soybeans. And it might surprise those of us on the hunt for Omega-3’s to learn that many fish do not create these heart-healthy nutrients — they consume them. By eating the plants fish eat, we get the same benefits. Already restaurants such as Beyond Sushi in Manhattan have crafted entire menus around these sea vegetables, and a bevy of gourmet chefs are working on recipes to make locavores swoon.

The best news is that these farms do more than grow food: in every sense, they restore rather than deplete. Matched up against land-based farming, these new ocean farms win every time. Seaweed and shellfish require no inputs—no land, no fertilizer, no fresh water—and since they grow three-dimensionally, they use space more efficiently than their land-based counterparts.

Shellfish and seaweed also act as filters, drawing out nitrogen and heavy metals — the primary objective of the Clean Water Act. While an important nutrient for humans, excess nitrogen from residential and agricultural runoff into the Sound regularly triggers large-scale algae blooms that deplete oxygen levels, killing marine life and forcing beach closures. With a single oyster filtering up to fifty gallons of water a day, even small farms can have measurable impacts on water quality. Farms in waters polluted by heavy metals are cultivating shellfish and seaweed not for food production, but for the continued rehabilitation of the Sound. One local initiative, spearheaded by the Bronx-based nonprofit Rock the Boat and Dr. Charles Yarish of the University of Connecticut, grows kelp and mussels in the Bronx River to filter out mercury and other pollutants. Other local projects are even building oyster reefs to protect New York from storm surges and flooding.

Still not convinced? Local ocean farms are also emerging as a viable source for alternative energy. As the fastest growing plant in the world, kelp is capable of producing over 2,000 gallons of biofuel per acre annually — five times higher than the ethanol produced by corn and up to 30 times more per acre than soybeans. With companies like RPM Sustainable Technologies already working with Long Island Sound farmers to source kelp for their biofuel operations, the promise of growing alternative energy in local waters is on its way to becoming a reality.

Ocean farms open both new and old pathways for economic development. A decentralized system of small-scale operations could revitalize life along the shoreline, first by creating new green jobs on farms and in the biofuel industry and then, as the sea recovers, perhaps opening up old fisheries and bringing back traditional means of making a living. In April, the New Amsterdam Market staged a one-day outdoor fish market at the old Fulton Docks in lower Manhattan, demonstrating that the neighborhood has the potential to be home to local seafood, not just financial markets.

Our urban sea promises to be one of our region’s great comeback stories. After forty years of slow but steady progress under the Clean Water Act, it is time to deputize a new generation of ocean farmers to protect our Sound and grow the green economy.

Bren Smith is the owner of Thimble Island Oyster Co, the first vertical multi-species ocean farm in Long Island Sound. Zan Romanoff is the Program Coordinator at the Yale Sustainable Food Project. Contact them at thimbleislandoysters@gmail.com.

Comments

  1. Chris
    Maryland, US
    October 11, 2012, 3:58 pm

    Suzi is correct in calling out the statement that “aquaculture has rightly earned a reputation for growing low quality seafood at the expense of the environment.” It is not accurate. You may be referring to bad practitioners, but lumping in all aquaculture hurts domestic finfish and shellfish farmers who operate under some of the strictest environmental and food safety regulations in the world. You need to make a distinction between bad practitioners (and the use of old examples) and modern, environmentally-responsible fish and shellfish farming.

  2. Suzi Dominy
    Hawaii
    October 10, 2012, 4:35 pm

    ‘Aquaculture has rightly earned a reputation for growing low quality seafood at the expense of the environment” – What an outrageous statement! Be careful with your words. You do untold damage with these throw-away lines. It is so tedious to see these totally erroneous statements, regurgitated from the outpourings of the $ multi-million funded, vested-interest environmental groups, rather than quality, factual reporting.

  3. Jay Weesterveld
    October 10, 2012, 11:03 am

    ….Little light on Kelp-as-fuel specifics, here.
    Being as kelp farming, much like Monsanto’s Soy Empire that has its base in GMO soy and extensive soaking of terrestrial systems with herbicide is likely to foster a similar GMO/herbicide-based monoculture approach, I notice that its mention is often quietly sandwiched into articles like this one, so as to get the “green” crowd on board before the permits are all signed off on.
    Kelp-as-fuel will spell the beginning of the end for marine biodiversity.
    Don’t be blinded by this greenwash

  4. abdulbagi ahmed
    sudan khartoum
    October 10, 2012, 7:41 am

    fisibility study need more servey